General Discussion

Phoenix61

(18,563 posts)

108. You have misread the situation.

Reply to Cowpunk (Reply #91)

Tue Sep 30, 2025, 03:52 PM

Tuesday

Walking out would be abandoning their troops and leaving them to fend for themselves.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

red dog 1 drmeow NEOH

151 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

WOW! The generals are having NONE of it! [View all] Faygo Kid Tuesday OP

They didn't get to where they are by cheerleading traitors. Kid Berwyn Tuesday #1

Malcolm Nance kinda sorta sums it up... mitch96 Tuesday #59

Nance speaks for me. Kid Berwyn Tuesday #61

"Fallujah, Louisiana" - he certainly summed it up well! Native Tuesday #103

People are saying generals, there are not 800 generals in our military there are 800 Eliot Rosewater Tuesday #106

They also had the officers principle staff in attendance. reACTIONary Tuesday #121

You are correct. soldierant Tuesday #135

Wow indeed. That would be something to see. . . . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Tuesday #2

I wish we had video. I would love to see it. Irish_Dem Tuesday #30

...... If there is a Santa Claus ... Tetrachloride Tuesday #48

Here's what TSF expected to see: yonder Tuesday #56

uh, oh... NameAlreadyTaken Tuesday #85

She was probably sent to a re-education camp for that. Dave Bowman Tuesday #86

... eppur_se_muova Tuesday #112

Dooplickit yonder Tuesday #57

Excellent! SheltieLover Tuesday #3

Great news malaise Tuesday #4

OMG..reports are that everyone in the audience did what the were supposed to do NCDem47 Tuesday #5

There is only one "monkee" left. valleyrogue 19 hrs ago #148

Generals don't applaud, generally. WhiskeyGrinder Tuesday #6

Yes Kaleva Tuesday #11

Hope 47 doesn't know this. pat_k Tuesday #12

Bet Hegseth and Trump didn't know that Raven123 Tuesday #37

Correct . obnoxiousdrunk Tuesday #44

Yes, that was explained earlier there are to be NO reactions positive or negative. Proper protocol. Fla Dem Tuesday #50

If they did applaud, wouldn't they do it generally ? eppur_se_muova Tuesday #113

can't believe it took this long tbh WhiskeyGrinder Tuesday #123

Admirably? BidenRocks Tuesday #130

! nt eppur_se_muova Tuesday #131

Well, they certainly wouldn't do it privately. Dr. Strange 19 hrs ago #146

It is very unusual for the brass to clap obamanut2012 Tuesday #7

I guess Dump realizes he hasn't turned us into North Korea mdbl Tuesday #14

Yes but every other US institution kisses Trump' ass 24/7. Irish_Dem Tuesday #34

And you know everything CR* does is for show BaronChocula Tuesday #79

Yes everything is a scene from the movie playing in his head. Irish_Dem Tuesday #82

"Movie playing in his head" - Spot on BaronChocula Tuesday #88

The judge is having a field day with the new Bimbo. Irish_Dem Tuesday #93

"...his rice paper ego"! calimary Tuesday #105

Light clapping at the end Maggiemayhem Tuesday #45

I caught about 20 secs berniesandersmittens Tuesday #8

Who said this? Trump or Hegseth? Irish_Dem Tuesday #36

Rump berniesandersmittens Tuesday #38

You have to be kidding me. This cannot be true he said this to Top Brass. Irish_Dem Tuesday #39

Here is a link berniesandersmittens Tuesday #40

Jebus God. Unbelievable. Irish_Dem Tuesday #43

Video in post #24. Honestly, it does come off as a joke. (n/t) thesquanderer Tuesday #54

But I'd wager Trump means it. ananda Tuesday #62

The jokes we tell reveal who we are. Irish_Dem Tuesday #84

Also, joking and gaslighting can be bully tells. ananda Tuesday #98

Turnip has never told an actual joke in his life. It's a warning which is thinly disguised as a joke. eppur_se_muova Tuesday #114

Bullies often pretend their abuse is "just a joke." Irish_Dem Tuesday #115

It could be what Al Franken referred to as "kidding on the square" Rob H. Tuesday #102

Where is post # 24? red dog 1 Tuesday #116

sorry I don't know how to link to a post anymore, with the new platform... thesquanderer Tuesday #128

from anyone else, maybe Skittles Tuesday #126

He said that at the beginning- watched it live Pachamama Tuesday #87

I cannot watch it. Irish_Dem Tuesday #89

Me too... Pachamama Tuesday #92

Every day Trump is more of a hated bastard. Irish_Dem Tuesday #94

F47's speech was a two barf bagger, LastLiberal in PalmSprings Tuesday #117

I wonder if they feel safe enough to even discuss it. Irish_Dem Tuesday #119

Both. soldierant Tuesday #136

Me too. HappyLarge Yesterday #142

I heard him. It's supposed to be a joke, until it's not. nt Ilsa Tuesday #90

It'd be really unusual if they did clap or cheer. Kaleva Tuesday #9

Or if they got up and left. yardwork Tuesday #35

I think clapping like trained seals will be a direct order. Irish_Dem Tuesday #41

I agree. They behaved like they were trained to behave. Kaleva Tuesday #58

The after-meeting collective thought: Totally Tunsie Tuesday #10

The regime has no clue about what it means to actually be RESPONSIBLE for pat_k Tuesday #20

He treated them like "Suckers and Losers" Champp Tuesday #21

Although I began my BlueMTexpat Tuesday #70

Kegsbreath is on a power trip. StarryNite Tuesday #13

Kegsbreath was a junior officer Seinan Sensei Tuesday #25

Yes. Guard Majors are a dime a dozen. MineralMan Tuesday #53

A major is not a junior officer Wifes husband Tuesday #64

Major's aren't junior grade DetroitLegalBeagle Tuesday #118

Secretary shitface went on a bit about fat, out of shape thomski64 Tuesday #78

I couldn't stand to listen to either of those A-holes. StarryNite Tuesday #95

Military applaud stuff worth applauding roscoeroscoe Tuesday #15

Waiting for Jake Tapper SocialDemocrat61 Tuesday #16

"Don't be fat" democratsruletheday Tuesday #17

Sounds like they'll honor their oath to the Consitution. Trump must be pissed! Fil1957 Tuesday #18

Make America 1930s Germany Again IronLionZion Tuesday #19

Wouldn't it be great if they marched en masse from the meeting to Congress... Reader Rabbit Tuesday #22

Only about 40 miles. Healthy enough generals should be able to do that march easily IronLionZion Tuesday #27

I know you're weren't being serious, but just so folks know onenote Tuesday #74

Right, the base is probably 10 miles across IronLionZion Tuesday #77

Going with numerous othere posters here. This is pretty much expected behavior, and really doesn't stopdiggin Tuesday #23

trump orders his generals to give him applause: "I've never walked into a room so silent before. LetMyPeopleVote Tuesday #24

How many of those guys voted for him? wolfie001 Tuesday #26

Pedofelon Bonespurs only deserves a straight jacket. Justice matters. Tuesday #47

When Trump tells this story Diraven Tuesday #65

"Just have a good time" ? Can anyone explain that to me? Deuxcents Tuesday #67

Idiot probably thinks they need his permission to applaud, so he was being magnanimous to "allow" it. llmart Tuesday #138

I hope er'tr seeing the definition of "closing ranks." Warpy Tuesday #28

US Air Force can't be too happy that Hegseth sent pilots into a possible ambush. Irish_Dem Tuesday #42

Not to mention, E. Normus Tuesday #69

It's never appropriate for generals to applaud PSPS Tuesday #29

WHere are you watching this or seeing reports on it? Amaryllis Tuesday #31

Trump got a message here. Don't expect the military to enforce a police state for him. patphil Tuesday #32

I'm hoping these military professionals held a second meeting Dr. T Tuesday #55

Most will fall in line like everybody else. drray23 Tuesday #76

This is it in a nutshell BamaRefugee Tuesday #81

I hope for the sake canetoad Tuesday #111

Sitting on their hands? Maybe. Standing up to him? No. Cowpunk Tuesday #33

How did they do that? nt Phoenix61 Tuesday #75

By literally sitting there and tolerating it. Cowpunk Tuesday #91

Not really. They sat there because they were ordered to go in haele Tuesday #99

You have misread the situation. Phoenix61 Tuesday #108

Hope they give Kegsbreath the death glare too! Jilly_in_VA Tuesday #46

I wouldn't reads too much into "audience reaction" here. We have no clue how individual audience members think or feel KPN Tuesday #49

Here's my comment, in deference to Ozzy: D. Spaulding Tuesday #51

A Jeb Bush once said Frasier Balzov Tuesday #52

I kept waiting for him to onethatcares 20 hrs ago #144

I truly hope this will push them toward refusing unlawful orders... CaptainTruth Tuesday #60

That huge flag behind hogsbreath, Codifer Tuesday #63

Mutiny! Blue Owl Tuesday #66

This stunt backfired LetMyPeopleVote Tuesday #68

"Please clap...". nt SeattleVet Tuesday #100

Or, "tough crowd tonight" and "hey, is this mic working?" nt JustABozoOnThisBus Tuesday #133

He said We have 2 N-words and you cant use either of them IcyPeas Tuesday #71

Recruitment must be getting difficult for the Armed Forces with the ICE mob offering $50k bonus money to GED types. NoMoreRepugs Tuesday #72

Draft is next n/t gay texan Tuesday #101

Wow!! Maine Abu El Banat Tuesday #73

MaddowBlog-Why Pete Hegseth's pitch to generals and admirals was even worse than expected LetMyPeopleVote Tuesday #80

trump's speech..... Bayard Tuesday #83

We'll see. I've lost faith and hope. C Moon Tuesday #96

possible military coup? IzzaNuDay Tuesday #97

I always had a much better feeling about the officer corps than about any of the other loci of power paulkienitz Tuesday #104

Thaml you. soldierant Tuesday #137

I don't know enough about NCO attitudes to have any hunch about them paulkienitz Tuesday #139

This photo of the Chief of Staff Army (silver hair matches the stars) with the soldierant Tuesday #140

saw that... but his role is a special case, he hangs out with high officers all day paulkienitz 19 hrs ago #145

Senior NCOs get there by getting promotions, soldierant 8 hrs ago #149

They would have done the same if it were any other President DetroitLegalBeagle Tuesday #107

WWII Battleship yankee87 Tuesday #109

Silence doesn't seem to me like 'standing up to' The Felon Oeditpus Rex Tuesday #110

That was the definition of "agressive indifference". SKKY Tuesday #120

One can only HOPE integrity B.See Tuesday #122

It was a brilliant speech! Turbineguy Tuesday #124

Sure, they might follow orders. But after today, the US Military high command despises their CIC. ancianita Tuesday #125

Hegseth will personally will be giving lessons on how to goose-step CentralMass Tuesday #127

At least one reporter said they gave him the "death stare" Jilly_in_VA Tuesday #129

We salute out of mutual respect. BidenRocks Tuesday #132

The Generals' conduct today ReRe Tuesday #134

Kick. N/T Upthevibe Tuesday #141

I wish that Rump and Kegsbreath could be sent to bootcamp for one day and let the drill sergeants I had back in the day LaMouffette 20 hrs ago #143

These officers are getting a special medal for yesterday LetMyPeopleVote 19 hrs ago #147

He's practically begging for a very constitutional military "intervention". roamer65 7 hrs ago #150

Richard Engel from 2016. Even more applicable now than back then. roamer65 7 hrs ago #151