General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Hegseth: "every warrior across our joint force is required to do PT [physical training] every duty day" [View all]mainer
(12,438 posts)"War still requires extraordinary courage from the men and women engaged in combat courage that, according to officers Ive spoken with, is rooted in a sense of honor, not swaggering machismo. Combatants also have to be physically fit enough to endure incredible hardship.
But they dont have to look like bodybuilders and anyway, only a small fraction of a modern army engages directly in combat. These days, war is conducted largely with machines and ranged weapons, and most of an armys personnel are employed, one way or another, keeping those machines and weapons in action and providing the intelligence that makes them effective. These noncombatants are every bit as essential to victory as front-line troops.
Actually, this has been true for a long time, at least since World War II. I very much doubt that Hegseth would consider the team led by Alan Turing, which broke Germanys Enigma code, or the group led by Joseph Rochefort, which broke Japans naval code, warriors even leaving aside the fact that Turing was gay. Yet they contributed as much to victory as any front-line soldier.
And the warrior ethos Hegseth touts is even less sufficient, on its own, to win wars today."
Edit history
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):