General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Democratic Socialism [View all]
"I think we just need to realize that the end goal is, ultimately, like social control of the means of production," said Joe Cernelli, a founding member of that West Virginia DSA chapter. "You know we don't just want to improve capitalism, we will ultimately want to get rid of it."
That's not just his idea; the DSA **views capitalism as an oppressive system** "We see it as fundamentally undemocratic," as DSA National Director Maria Svart put it. Here's how she sums up what the group wants:
"When it comes right down to it, we believe people need to be able to live a dignified life. I mean, there are certain things that should not be left up to the market," she said.
Removing some parts of the economy from the forces of the free market, for example. In other words, socialism.
But beyond that, the group advocates for some pretty revolutionary changes to democracy, like abolishing the Senate. The DSA calls it "extremely unrepresentative" for the way it gives both tiny and huge states alike two senators each the group would like to replace it with a more representative body.
The country and the attitudes of most American voters are pretty far from this vision, though, so the DSA is willing to pursue policies that fall short of its ultimate goals. Health care is one example the group backs "Medicare for All" where the government provides health insurance, but the private sector supplies the doctors and hospitals. But many DSA members would prefer a system where the government employs the doctors themselves. (aka gaslighting them)
"I think we could do better than Bernie, but I think it was definitely a good start," he said. "There are some policies that I think he's been a little too soft on, a little too Democrat for me."
And likewise, Svart says, the group sees Sanders as an "ally" while also wanting to go further than he does on many areas. (aka too far left for even Bernie Sanders. .WOW)
https://www.npr.org/2018/07/26/630960719/what-you-need-to-know-about-the-democratic-socialists-of-america
And another very good article from the Nation that I think should be examined not dismissed:
Why I Just Quit DSA
After over four decades as a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, one of the groups founding members is leaving in sorrow and anger.
All well and goodexcept for the return of the entryists. Suddenly, in the eyes of revolutionary purists in a host of small competing sects, DSA was no longer to be sneered at as just a reformist swamp. Why rob banks? career criminal Willie Sutton was once allegedly asked by a reporter. Because thats where the money is, he replied. The exchange is apocryphal, but substitute warm bodies for cold cash, and it offers a concise explanation for DSAs sudden attractiveness to sectarian strategists. Unknown numbershundreds, perhaps morestarted joining in 2016, some of them former members of defunct Marxist-Leninist groups, others (in violation of DSA bylaws) still belonging to and carrying out the agendas of such groups. They proceeded to quarrel and compete among themselves, splitting and recombining under various banners like Red Star, Marxist Unity Group, and even the Communist Caucus. But they remained united in one overarching shared aimto take a well-meaning, not particularly well-organized, and essentially social democratic organization still committed in practice to the original DSA vision of creating the left wing of the possible, and reinvent it as the mass vanguard party of the proletariat that somehow they had never been able to pull off while operating under their own banners of deepest red.
DSA, meanwhile, thrived between 2016 and 2020because it proved it could win victories in the here-and-now, give-and-take world of electoral politics. And that, ironically, was intolerable to the entryists (who preferred to refer to themselves as partyists), because they didnt want socialists to remain as a wing of, or even a loyal opposition within the Democratic Party. They wanted a break, in the not terribly distant future, from the intolerable compromises required to appeal to mainstream voters and to compromise with mainstream politicians. And they also believed that DSA members elected to public office were, first and foremost, obliged to follow the positions adopted by the organization, rather than their constituents or their own conscience, as if they were already subordinate to the dictates of an old-fashioned Marxist-Leninist central committee.
https://www.thenation.com/article/activism/quit-dsa-gaza-israel/
And this too
OPEN LETTER
Out of Loyalty to Democratic Socialism: Why We Are Leaving DSA
Twenty-four longtime members of the Democratic Socialists of America explain why theyre leaving the organization.
https://newrepublic.com/article/176781/open-letter-why-leaving-democratic-socialists-america
I'm quite happy to stay a Social Democrat myself....My political hero is FDR, so I support Regulated Capitalism ...I don't want it eliminated.
