Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

DFW

(60,880 posts)
71. Simple
Sun Jun 28, 2026, 02:13 PM
Sunday

Another sales tax would be like any other sales tax. It would have to be collected individually on every single transaction. That means millions or tens of millions if transactions per month. Plus: it would affect the citizens of each state differently, depending on how much their own sales taxes are. People living states with high state sales taxes would be unfairly hit, where people living in states with low (or no) state sales taxes would have it easier. I.e. it would hit people living in states like New York, California and Illinois way harder than people living in states like New Hampshire. What Congress would vote for a national sales tax that would punish people for living in certain (incidentally mostly blue) states? Plus the thousands of additional accountants/auditors that would have to be hired to administer the new bureaucracy.

I think that supporting anything of the sort would be electoral suicide. Plus, in every country here in Europe that has a VAT, it has proved to be government heroin. Once they started, almost all at 10% it has only risen, now between 19% and 25% in most EU countries. If the cost of everything went up overnight by 25% in the USAJ, who would boast about voting for that?

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

30 years ago lapfog_1 Jun 25 #1
We can only hope popsdenver Jun 25 #2
I can't look. Thanks for posting. I just can't look. Have a great day. twodogsbarking Jun 25 #3
It was peanuts compared to what you'd pay back in the USA DFW Jun 25 #9
I'm glad to see you posting today& that you are well enough to do so. irisblue Jun 25 #4
Thanks for the kind words! DFW Jun 25 #6
Best wishes DFW and thanks for the perspective. ED Evolve Dammit Jun 25 #5
No sweat! I haven't been in an American hospital overnight since 2011. DFW Jun 25 #7
OMG. Thats why med bills are #1 cause of bankruptcy. Evolve Dammit Saturday #65
That was a weird deal with the billing. DFW Sunday #67
It's a money extraction racket, not "health care." Thanks for the info, and yes it is perverse. I just got a denial for Evolve Dammit Wednesday #73
Here's our Canadian Health story Tripper11 Jun 25 #8
Here in Germany DFW Jun 25 #14
Stay Well DFW! We love your posts from across the pond. joanbarnes Jun 25 #10
If I have not been the cause of fatal boredom DFW Jun 26 #37
Heheh blm Jun 26 #52
What good authority? DFW Sunday #68
😁 blm Sunday #69
Ain't freedom to choose your poison relogic Jun 25 #11
Actually, my Doctor in Dallas said I was right to get the procedure done in Germany DFW Jun 25 #15
Yes relogic Jun 25 #18
I left Pennsylvania in 1975, so I'm in the dark about what it is like there now DFW Jun 25 #20
My dear PA relogic Jun 25 #22
We love you, DFW. So happy to hear that everything is going well for you! ❤️ littlemissmartypants Jun 25 #12
As well as can be hoped for, anyway!! I am grateful for your comment!! DFW Jun 25 #21
Many Happy Returns to your bride and condolences for the loss of her mom. ... littlemissmartypants Jun 25 #23
It's amazing what can happen in fifty years! DFW Jun 25 #24
It really is! 🌞❤️ littlemissmartypants Jun 25 #25
Northern Germany, my husband's father Tree Lady Jun 25 #29
You can still get the citizenship without moving there right away. DFW Jun 26 #42
Happy for your outcome but disappointed in the bill......... KS Toronado Jun 25 #13
I'm a legal resident here, so you heard wrong DFW Jun 25 #17
The 19% VAT tax is also used to pay for many of those "free" services MichMan Jun 26 #55
In the US, each state can levy its own state sales tax DFW Sunday #66
There are state and local income taxes on top of the federal income tax MichMan Sunday #70
Simple DFW Sunday #71
Whenever health care is brought up, there are always statements about other countries and how we need to emulate them. MichMan Sunday #72
My Angiogram cost $20k 14 yrs ago. Jacson6 Jun 25 #16
Now THAT is a typical horror story, the likes of which I hear often DFW Jun 25 #19
Living the life. Love that you are at it. cachukis Jun 25 #26
I'm still alive DFW Jun 26 #43
Wisdom pays dividends. cachukis Jun 26 #44
Wow, what a great happy ending story! DFW Jun 26 #45
The best of times, the worst of times. cachukis Jun 26 #46
Sometimes the simple things stand out DFW Jun 26 #47
My grandfather was a supervisor in the Back Bay cachukis Jun 26 #49
Thanks, we intend to try! DFW Jun 26 #54
The Scots certainly woke it up. cachukis Jun 26 #56
It would be basically free here in Sweden, so there's that. Celerity Jun 25 #27
Is that for legal residents, or anyone who shows up? DFW Jun 26 #33
Legal residents. You do not have to be a citizen, just be living here legally. You cannot (of course) come here as a Celerity Jun 26 #35
Medical tourism was, for a while, at least, a concern in Canada DFW Jun 26 #36
This message was self-deleted by its author Celerity Jun 25 #28
I'm glad you are doing well MustLoveBeagles Jun 25 #30
Thanks! DFW Jun 26 #34
Glad you are ok. I slipped and fell on stairs in a hotel in Beilstein, Germany and dislocated a finger. surfered Jun 25 #31
That sounds typical for all three countries DFW Jun 26 #32
We are in Germany Old Crank Jun 26 #38
If either of you had a German employer, that made all the difference. DFW Jun 26 #40
We took TK insurance Old Crank Jun 26 #58
Thanks! Yes, it so seems to have been successful. DFW Saturday #59
My daughter did her BA abroad in France - TBF Jun 26 #39
Germany is different, not surprisingly. DFW Jun 26 #41
Recommended. H2O Man Jun 26 #48
A socialist country here in Europe. DFW Jun 26 #50
Medical care and education. H2O Man Jun 26 #53
Hospital Bill here in Canada (for Canadians, naturalized included) Justice matters. Jun 26 #51
Canada seems to have learned from the mistakes of other countries. DFW Saturday #60
Thank you for this touching reply. Justice matters. Saturday #64
I've been thinking of you... róisín_dubh Jun 26 #57
My last cardiac episode in the USA was in 2011. DFW Saturday #61
I still feel that it should be completely free, paid with higher taxes Polybius Saturday #62
Thanks for the well-wishes DFW Saturday #63
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Hospital Bill, German sty...»Reply #71